Cropsey (2009)
Cropsey begins by exploring the eerie urban legend of a figure known as “Cropsey.” In New York City, this boogeyman-like character has haunted the imaginations of children for generations. But as the film unfolds, it delves deeper into a chilling real-life mystery.
The heart of the documentary lies in the story of Andre Rand, a convicted child kidnapper from Staten Island. Rand’s known or suspected crimes in the 1970s and ’80s may have inspired or been attributed to the infamous “Cropsey.” The filmmakers, Joshua Zeman and Barbara Brancaccio, meticulously weave together various elements to create a compelling narrative:
- Urban Legends and Oral Tradition: They explore the power of urban legends—the stories passed down through generations that shape our fears and beliefs. The legend of Cropsey serves as a backdrop, drawing viewers into the dark corners of Staten Island’s collective psyche.
- Missing Children: The film investigates the disappearance of several children from the region. One case stands out—the kidnapping of a 13-year-old girl with Down’s Syndrome. As the filmmakers dig deeper, they uncover disturbing connections that make the legend of Cropsey feel all too real.
- Andre Rand’s Story: Rand, who worked at the notorious Willowbrook State School on Staten Island, becomes the central figure. He occasionally lived in campsites near the facility. The filmmakers attempt to interview Rand, but his reluctance and changing decisions add to the intrigue.
- Courtroom Drama: Rand’s court case in 2004 became one of the longest pre-trial motions in New York State history. The film features interviews with Rand’s defense attorneys, police investigators, and families of missing children. The accuracy of allegations against Rand is hotly debated.
- Community Catharsis: Staten Island grapples with its obsession over the case. The need for closure and catharsis drives the community’s fascination with Cropsey and Rand.
Cropsey premiered at the Tribeca Film Festival in 2009, garnering an overwhelmingly positive critical reception. It skillfully blurs the lines between legend and reality, leaving viewers riveted and bone-chilled. The film serves as both a gripping documentary and an unsettling exploration of the human psyche
