How to Kill a Human Being (2008)
“How to Kill a Human Being” is a thought-provoking documentary that delves into the science of execution and the ethical dilemmas surrounding capital punishment. Former Conservative MP Michael Portillo leads this exploration, pushing his own body to the brink of death in the process.
The film begins by acknowledging that 55 countries still practice the death penalty. Portillo’s quest is to understand what it feels like to be executed, and he willingly undergoes experiments that test the limits of human endurance. His investigation centers on finding a fundamentally humane method of execution.
The documentary sheds light on several critical aspects:
- Lethal Injection: Portillo examines the widely used lethal injection method. As the American Supreme Court investigates whether this method causes unnecessary pain for prisoners, he seeks to find a solution that balances justice with compassion.
- The Death Penalty Debate: The film grapples with the complexities of capital punishment. Portillo’s personal struggle mirrors the broader societal debate: Is it ever justifiable to take a human life as punishment? The documentary doesn’t shy away from the emotional and moral dimensions of this question.
- Inhumane Practices: Portillo highlights the flaws in execution procedures. He questions why some executions are unnecessarily prolonged, painful, and horrifying. The focus isn’t on abolishing the death penalty but rather on ensuring that if it exists, it is carried out swiftly and with minimal suffering.
- Victims and Justice: The film acknowledges the pain of victims and their families. However, it also emphasizes that a civilized society relies on laws and judicial processes rather than personal vengeance. The death penalty should not perpetuate suffering; it should serve justice efficiently.
- Mental Health and Innocence: Portillo underscores that those sentenced to death often include people with severe mental health conditions or tragic life circumstances. Innocent individuals have also faced execution. The documentary challenges viewers to consider the humanity of those on death row.
In summary, “How to Kill a Human Being” prompts viewers to confront uncomfortable truths about capital punishment. It advocates for a more humane approach, urging society to prioritize swift and painless executions if they are to occur at all. The film leaves us pondering the delicate balance between justice, compassion, and the sanctity of life.
