Right to Fail (2019)
The Right to Fail is a compelling documentary that delves into the lives of New Yorkers with severe mental illnesses. Produced by FRONTLINE in collaboration with ProPublica, this investigative film sheds light on a critical issue: the transition of individuals from adult homes to independent living in supported housing.
The Background
In 2014, a federal court order granted thousands of New Yorkers the opportunity to live independently in apartments. This initiative aimed to provide them with a chance to reclaim their autonomy and dignity. However, the reality turned out to be far more complex.
The Journey
The documentary follows the stories of those who made this transition. It explores the challenges they faced, the gaps in support systems, and the consequences of the move. The central question emerges: Can people with severe mental illnesses truly thrive when given the right to live on their own?
System Failures
As FRONTLINE and ProPublica investigate, they uncover more than two dozen cases where the system failed—sometimes with deadly consequences. The promise of independence collided with harsh realities, leaving vulnerable individuals exposed to risks. The film highlights the struggles, vulnerabilities, and triumphs of those caught in this delicate balance.
Human Dignity
“I want to live like a human being,” one interviewee expresses. This sentiment encapsulates the heart of the matter. The right to fail is not just about autonomy; it’s about recognizing the humanity of each person, regardless of their mental health challenges.
Reflection
Right to Fail forces us to confront uncomfortable questions. How do we support those with mental illnesses without compromising their safety? Can we dismantle the implicit notion that some lives are expendable? The documentary invites viewers to grapple with these complexities and advocate for a more compassionate and effective system.
In a world where independence and vulnerability intersect, Right to Fail serves as a poignant reminder that every life deserves dignity, care, and the chance to thrive.
